Butterfly Valve vs Ball Valve: Key Differences, Pros & Cons [2026 Guide]
Butterfly valves and ball valves are the two most widely used quarter-turn valves in industrial piping systems. While both operate with a 90° rotation, their design, performance, and cost differ significantly. This guide covers everything you need to know to choose the right valve for your application.
Table of Contents
1. Quick Comparison: Butterfly Valve vs Ball Valve
| Parameter | Butterfly Valve | Ball Valve |
|---|---|---|
| Closure Element | Rotating disc | Hollow sphere (ball) with bore |
| Operation | Quarter-turn (90°) | Quarter-turn (90°) |
| Flow Path | Disc stays in flow — partial obstruction | Full-bore — unobstructed when open |
| Shutoff | Good (resilient seat) to excellent (metal seat) | Excellent — bubble-tight (Class VI) |
| Size Range | 2" to 72" (up to 120") | ½" to 48" |
| Pressure Class | Class 150–300 (triple offset: up to 600) | Class 150–2500 |
| Temperature | -40°C to 400°C (metal seat: 700°C) | -46°C to 538°C |
| Throttling | ✓ Good — proportional control | ✗ Poor — causes seat damage |
| Weight | Very light — up to 80% lighter | Heavy — solid ball + body |
| Cost | 40–80% cheaper (especially large sizes) | Higher cost |
| Face-to-Face | Very compact (wafer/lug design) | Longer — needs flanged body |
| Piggable | ✗ No — disc blocks passage | ✓ Yes — full bore |
| Fire-Safe | Available (API 607) | Available (API 607/6FA) |
| Common Standards | API 609, EN 593, MSS SP-67 | API 608, API 6D, ASME B16.34 |
2. How Each Valve Works
Butterfly Valve — Rotating Disc
A butterfly valve has a circular disc mounted on a shaft (stem) running through the center of the pipe. When the handle or actuator turns 90°, the disc rotates from perpendicular (closed) to parallel (open) to the flow. Even in the fully open position, the disc and stem remain inside the pipe bore, creating a slight flow restriction.
Butterfly valves come in three main designs:
- Concentric (Centric): Stem passes through the center of the disc. Simple, cost-effective. Used for water, air, and low-pressure service. EPDM or NBR rubber seat.
- Double Offset (High Performance): Stem is offset from the disc center and pipe center. Reduces seat wear on opening/closing. PTFE or metal seat. Suitable for higher pressures and temperatures.
- Triple Offset: Three offsets plus a conical seating surface. Metal-to-metal seal. Bubble-tight shutoff. Used for high-pressure, high-temperature, and critical service. Competes with ball valves.
Ball Valve — Rotating Sphere
A ball valve uses a hollow, perforated sphere (ball) that sits between two sealing rings (seats). When the handle turns 90°, the bore aligns with the pipe for full flow. When closed, the solid part of the ball faces the flow, providing a tight seal. The key advantage: when fully open, the bore is completely unobstructed — equal to the pipe ID in full-bore designs.
Ball valves come in several configurations:
- Floating Ball: Ball is held in place by the seats. Pressure pushes the ball against the downstream seat for sealing. Common in sizes up to 8". Cost-effective.
- Trunnion Mounted: Ball is mechanically anchored by a trunnion (pivot). Reduces torque in large sizes. Required for high-pressure and large-diameter applications.
- Full Bore: Ball bore equals pipe bore. Zero flow restriction. Required for piggable pipelines.
- Reduced Bore: Ball bore is one size smaller than pipe bore. Lower cost and lighter weight. Acceptable for most applications.
3. Key Design Differences
Flow Characteristics
This is the most important practical difference. A ball valve provides a full, unobstructed flow path when open — the bore is essentially a straight pipe section. A butterfly valve always has the disc and stem sitting in the flow, causing turbulence and pressure drop.
For applications where low pressure drop is critical (e.g., large diameter water mains, HVAC systems), this difference matters. For pipeline applications requiring pigging (sending a cleaning device through the pipe), only full-bore ball valves work.
Sealing Performance
Ball valves generally provide superior sealing. The ball-to-seat contact creates a bubble-tight seal (ANSI/FCI 70-2 Class VI). This makes them the standard choice for:
- Hazardous and toxic media
- Fugitive emission control
- Gas service where even minor leakage is unacceptable
- High-pressure service
Butterfly valves with resilient (rubber) seats provide good sealing for water and air. Triple offset butterfly valves with metal seats approach ball valve sealing performance and are rated for fire-safe and zero-leakage service.
Size and Weight
Butterfly valves dominate in large sizes. A 24" butterfly valve weighs roughly 150-200 kg, while a 24" ball valve weighs 800-2000 kg. This 4-10x weight difference affects:
- Pipe support requirements
- Actuator sizing (butterfly needs smaller actuator)
- Installation cost and time
- Shipping and handling
4. Advantages & Disadvantages
Butterfly Valve — Advantages
- Low cost — 40-80% cheaper than ball valves in equivalent sizes
- Lightweight — up to 80% lighter, reducing pipe support needs
- Compact — wafer design fits between flanges with minimal face-to-face
- Good for throttling — proportional flow control at any disc angle
- Large sizes available — up to 72" (even 120" custom)
- Low operating torque — easy to automate with smaller actuators
- Fast operation — quarter-turn like ball valves
Butterfly Valve — Disadvantages
- Flow restriction — disc always in the flow path, causing pressure drop
- Not piggable — disc blocks pipeline cleaning tools
- Limited pressure rating — standard types limited to Class 150-300
- Seat wear — resilient seats wear faster than ball valve seats
- Cavitation risk — throttling at high differential pressure can cause cavitation
Ball Valve — Advantages
- Bubble-tight shutoff — Class VI leakage rate, zero leakage
- Full-bore option — unrestricted flow, suitable for pigging
- High pressure ratings — up to Class 2500 (6,170 PSI)
- Wide temperature range — cryogenic (-196°C) to high temperature (538°C)
- Low maintenance — self-cleaning ball design, durable PTFE/metal seats
- Bidirectional sealing — seals in both flow directions
Ball Valve — Disadvantages
- Higher cost — especially in large sizes (12" and above)
- Heavy weight — solid ball and body add significant weight
- Not suitable for throttling — partial opening causes seat erosion
- Larger actuators needed — higher torque requirement in larger sizes
- Size limitation — practical limit around 48" (larger = extremely expensive)
5. Pressure & Temperature Ratings
| Valve Type | Pressure Class | Max Pressure (PSI) | Temperature Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Concentric Butterfly | Class 150 | ~285 PSI | -20°C to 120°C (rubber seat) |
| Double Offset Butterfly | Class 150–300 | ~740 PSI | -40°C to 400°C |
| Triple Offset Butterfly | Class 150–600 | ~1,480 PSI | -196°C to 700°C (metal seat) |
| Floating Ball Valve | Class 150–600 | ~1,480 PSI | -46°C to 260°C |
| Trunnion Ball Valve | Class 150–2500 | ~6,170 PSI | -46°C to 538°C |
Key takeaway: For pressure ratings above Class 300, ball valves (trunnion mounted) are the standard choice. Triple offset butterfly valves can reach Class 600 but at a cost that approaches trunnion ball valves.
6. Cost Comparison
Cost is often the deciding factor. Here's a rough comparison for Class 150, carbon steel (WCB), flanged valves:
| Size | Butterfly Valve (Wafer) | Ball Valve (Flanged) | Savings with Butterfly |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4" | ₹3,000 – ₹5,000 | ₹8,000 – ₹15,000 | ~60% |
| 6" | ₹5,000 – ₹8,000 | ₹15,000 – ₹30,000 | ~65% |
| 8" | ₹8,000 – ₹12,000 | ₹25,000 – ₹50,000 | ~70% |
| 10" | ₹12,000 – ₹18,000 | ₹50,000 – ₹100,000 | ~75% |
| 12" | ₹18,000 – ₹25,000 | ₹80,000 – ₹150,000 | ~80% |
| 16" | ₹30,000 – ₹45,000 | ₹150,000 – ₹300,000 | ~80% |
| 24" | ₹60,000 – ₹100,000 | ₹500,000 – ₹1,000,000 | ~85% |
Prices are indicative for carbon steel Class 150. Stainless steel and alloy steel valves will be 2-3x higher. Contact Supreme Valves India for current pricing.
7. When to Use Each Valve
Choose a Butterfly Valve When:
- Size is 6" and above (cost advantage is dramatic)
- Pressure is Class 150 or 300
- You need flow control / throttling
- Media is water, air, steam, or general chemicals
- Weight and space are constraints (wafer design)
- Budget is a priority — large projects with many valves
- Application: HVAC, water treatment, fire protection, cooling water, general isolation
Choose a Ball Valve When:
- You need bubble-tight shutoff (zero leakage)
- Pressure is Class 300 and above
- Size is ½" to 8" (ball valves are cost-competitive here)
- Media is hazardous, toxic, flammable, or corrosive
- Pipeline requires pigging (full-bore ball valve)
- Service is cryogenic or high temperature
- Application: oil & gas pipelines, chemical plants, refineries, LNG, subsea
8. Industry Applications
| Industry / Application | Preferred Valve | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Water treatment plants | Butterfly | Large sizes, low pressure, cost-effective |
| HVAC systems | Butterfly | Throttling capability, compact, lightweight |
| Fire protection | Butterfly | UL/FM listed, fast operation, large sizes |
| Oil & gas pipelines | Ball | Piggable, high pressure, bubble-tight |
| Chemical processing | Ball | Zero leakage, corrosion-resistant alloys |
| LNG / Cryogenic | Ball | Extended bonnet, cryogenic temperature |
| Refinery process lines | Ball | Fire-safe, high pressure, toxic media |
| Cooling water systems | Butterfly | Large bore, low pressure, throttling |
| Steam service | Both (depends on size) | Triple offset butterfly or ball valve |
| Instrument isolation | Ball | Small size (½"–2"), tight shutoff |
9. Selection Decision Chart
Use this quick decision logic:
- Is the pressure above Class 300? → Ball valve
- Is the size below 2"? → Ball valve (butterfly valves start at 2")
- Do you need pigging capability? → Full-bore ball valve
- Is the media hazardous or toxic? → Ball valve (bubble-tight shutoff)
- Is the size 10" or larger at Class 150? → Butterfly valve (massive cost savings)
- Do you need throttling / flow control? → Butterfly valve
- Is it water, air, HVAC, or fire protection? → Butterfly valve
- Everything else 4"–8" at Class 150–300? → Compare cost — butterfly is cheaper, ball seals better
Need Help Choosing Between Butterfly and Ball Valves?
Our engineers can review your line list and recommend the right valve for each application.